Top streaming subscription retention factors in 2026

In 2026, streaming platforms face a growing challenge: more than one in three subscribers plan to cancel at least one video streaming service this year. As inflation pressures persist and subscription costs continue to rise, consumers are reassessing what they really need – and what they can live without.

But what determines whether a service stays or goes? Our latest consumer trends research explores the key retention factors that influence how consumers in the US and UK make those decisions.

Analysing data from two nationally-representative surveys with a total of 6,000 respondents, we take a closer look at what matters most to today’s streaming subscribers, and what brands can do to remain essential.

US insights

Usage and content lead the way

Regular personal engagement with a streaming service is the most powerful predictor of subscription retention. Half (50%) of American streaming subscribers say regular usage is the top reason they keep a service, making it the dominant factor across all age, gender, and income groups.

However, this behavior becomes more pronounced with age: 43% of 18–24-year-olds cite usage as their primary retention factor, compared to 56% of 55–64-year-olds. It suggests that younger consumers may be more experimental with services, while older subscribers stick with platforms that have become part of their routine.

Content quality comes second at 24% overall, and it plays a slightly more important role for younger audiences, with 26% of 18–24s and 27% of 25–34s saying it’s their top factor. Men also place greater emphasis on content quality (26%) than women (23%), reinforcing the importance of consistently compelling programming, especially when trying to attract or retain younger male audiences.

Price comparison with competitors only influences 13% of decisions, despite the cost of living being a growing concern. This figure declines with age, from 15% among 18–24-year-olds to just 10% among 55–64s. It’s clear that while price may matter, it’s not the primary metric people use to decide what stays or goes.

The role of household usage and decision dynamics

Beyond individual preferences, 11% of subscribers say household usage influences their decision to keep a service. This shared-value dynamic is more prominent among younger consumers (14% of 18–24s) and less important for older ones (8% of 55–64s), who may make more independent decisions.

Interestingly, only 2% of US consumers maintain their subscriptions without evaluating them, meaning the vast majority are actively assessing whether each service earns its place. This habit of frequent reassessment makes retention harder and increases the pressure on platforms to constantly prove their value.

Across all income brackets, regular usage remains the top driver of retention, cited by around half of respondents. Content quality is again the consistent second priority (23–24%), while price comparison hovers between 12–14%, showing that bargain hunting is not exclusive to lower-income groups.

What frustrates US streaming subscribers

The top frustration by far is rising prices, cited by 62% of respondents. This suggests that while cost isn’t the main factor in retention, it is the biggest pain point. Frequent or uncommunicated price hikes risk triggering cancellations, particularly if users don’t feel the content or value is keeping pace.

The second most common frustration is ads on paid plans, with 39% of consumers saying this undermines their experience. It’s a clear sign that subscribers expect an ad-free environment once they’re paying, and that failure to deliver on this promise can erode trust quickly.

Subscription fatigue is another significant issue, with 26% saying they’re overwhelmed by the number of platforms. This indicates that bundling, consolidation, or curated recommendations may play a future role in improving satisfaction.

Other common pain points include auto-renewals and surprise charges (23%), password-sharing restrictions (19%), and the general sense that platforms aren’t transparent or fair in how they manage subscriptions. Just 9% of US subscribers say they have no frustrations at all, showing that almost everyone sees room for improvement.

UK insights

Value and flexibility are king

For UK consumers, 2026 is all about control and affordability when it comes to streaming subscriptions. Our data shows that value for money is the top priority for 35% of subscribers, making it the leading factor across all age, gender, and income groups. This uniform concern over affordability speaks to the growing scrutiny of monthly spending in a climate of rising living costs and widespread subscription fatigue.

Closely following value is a desire for flexibility: 32% of consumers prioritise services that offer easy cancellation, pausing or restarting, and 22% want subscriptions that don’t come with cancellation fees. These preferences show that consumers are demanding more freedom from their subscriptions, and will favour platforms that give them control without friction.

Interestingly, price stability ranks third overall, with 25% of respondents saying they want subscriptions that don’t keep increasing in price. This is especially important among younger consumers, where around 27% of 18–44 year-olds prioritise stable pricing. Together, these three factors suggest consumers are tired of feeling locked in or priced out. They want transparency, consistency, and freedom to manage their subscriptions on their terms.

Content still matters, but it’s not the main driver

While streaming services have traditionally competed on content quality, UK consumers are signalling that practical value now outweighs premium libraries. Only 23% of respondents cite high-quality content as a top priority, putting it behind flexibility and pricing. That number rises slightly among men (26%) and higher earners (31%), but even in those groups, it doesn’t lead.

Similarly, subscriptions based on special interests are important to 23% of consumers, suggesting niche content can still drive retention — but only if the price and flexibility boxes are ticked first. For younger consumers and higher earners, personalisation and bundles are more appealing: multi-service subscriptions like Amazon Prime appeal to 24% of 25–34 year-olds, and 26% of those earning over £75k.

Ad-free experiences are a lower priority, viewed as essential by just 16% overall. However, there’s a notable generational split: 23% of 18–24 year-olds want subscriptions without ads, compared to only around 10% of those aged 45–64. This suggests that while ad-free viewing can still be a differentiator, it’s a generational preference rather than a universal one.

Brand recognition ranks lowest across the board, with only 6–12% of consumers prioritising it. This opens up opportunities for challenger platforms and niche streamers that offer better value or more flexible models.

Demographic and behavioural insights into UK streaming choices

The prioritisation of value and flexibility is remarkably consistent across age, gender, and income groups, but there are some notable nuances in the data.

Value for money leads across all age groups, with more than a third of consumers ranking it as their top priority. This shows that affordability is a cross-generational concern in 2026, not just limited to younger or lower-income households.

Flexibility features show the starkest gender divide: 36% of women prioritise easy cancellation, pausing and restarting, compared to 28% of men. Women are also more concerned with price stability, with 27% selecting it as a key factor, versus 23% of men. Men, on the other hand, are more likely to prioritise high-quality content (26% vs 20%).

When it comes to income, those earning over £75k are more likely to prioritise content quality (31%) and bundled services (26%), while lower earners are more focused on pricing and flexibility: 31% want easy cancellation, and 24% want stable pricing. Both groups express similar concern about cancellation fees (20%), reinforcing the importance of reducing friction across the board.

This data reinforces that while cost and control dominate overall, demographic-specific preferences offer opportunities for segmentation, messaging, and value framing.

Top 5 takeaways for streaming brands in 2026

1. Subscribers keep what they use. Focus on increasing regular engagement through habit-forming UX and relevant content.
2. Subscriptions have to feel ‘worth it’. Lead with value, clear pricing, and maximum flexibility.
3. Transparency matters. From ad loads to renewal policies, anything that feels unfair or misleading will erode trust.
4. Frustrations are common. Whether it’s price hikes, ads, or password crackdowns, most subscribers have a reason to cancel so make sure your service gives them more reasons to stay.
5. The retention strategy isn’t one-size-fits-all. Understand your specific audience, meet their expectations, and adapt your model to deliver lasting value.

Want to hear the headlines from Attest’s 2026 Consumer trends reports in under 10 minutes? Check out our on-demand webinars.