4 Honest Brands Wearing Their Heart on Their Sleeve

June 22, 2018 - 5 minute read

For centuries, philosophers and laymen have pondered the value of honesty. In a society where it’s widely accepted that being dishonest is a poor trait in a human being, why are the rules different for brands?

The news fails to be truly shocking, more so disappointing, when it’s frequently revealed that a brand has been dishonest to the public in some way. In fact, it’s a worryingly accepted norm that brands are opaque, hiding some things (often most things) from the outside world.

Inter-competition between brands is somewhat to blame for this secrecy. KFC wouldn’t want their supply chain known, else risk discovery of their secret recipe, for instance.

Increasingly, though, there’s an emerging trend for brands to include honesty in their policies and strategies. We look at four brands who are successfully embodying the virtue in at least some of their strategies.

1. Oasis

The rising popularity of social media, and the subsequent content overload for consumers, is forcing brands to innovate in order to stand out from competitors. And honesty, in our money-focussed society, often goes hand in hand with a tongue-in-cheek sense of humour about one’s role in the grand scheme of things. A strategy not widely embraced, but successfully implemented by a chosen few.

Oasis take this to the extreme with their #RefreshingStuff campaign. Commenting deliberately on one of the most prevalent trends advertising agencies are currently adopting: cause marketing. By joining an ethical bandwagon (social justice, mainly) for the public purpose of spreading awareness of a cause, brands can achieve the contrary private purpose of encouraging cash flow in their direction.

Oasis is publicly accusing other brands of creating advertising campaigns that reflect a superficial ethical standpoint, that the brand doesn’t actually buy in to, much less embody. Meanwhile, Oasis themselves pitch an external message which does reflect their internal standpoint; that no one brand can change the world, and any brand who purports to be able to is pulling the wool over consumers’ eyes.

 

 

The feature of their current campaign, The Togetherness Bottle, satirises the trend for brands encouraging social justice through advertising campaigns (à la Heineken).

Admittedly, Oasis are also trying to make money, and perhaps they think the way to a consumer’s wallet is through their funny bone rather than their heart, but their honest portrayal of a growing advertising trend does feel, frankly, refreshing.

 

2. Oatly

Oatly’s honesty is most clearly portrayed in their social media marketing campaigns, notably their Instagram account.

Aimed at a health-conscious millennial market, they haven’t opted for the cheeky, headline-worthy approach of Oasis, but rather a cut-the-crap, honesty’s-the-best-policy strategy. Their consumers are smart people, they can make up their own mind about what products to buy.

Oatly3

By breaking the traditional rules of marketing - build a vision, present a story to encourage consumers to buy into that vision - Oatly stand out in crowded social media platforms with their straight-up approach. They make oat milk. They want you to buy it. That’s it.

Oatly2

3. Starbucks

Sorry, what? Starbucks? In a list of honest brands? You must have a short memory.

You’d be forgiven for thinking any of these thoughts. Admittedly, Starbucks don’t have a squeaky-clean track record when it comes to being honest with their finances.

But in the wake of a social justice scandal caused by the insensitivity of a manager of one of their Philadelphia coffee shops, it might not have shocked many people if the brand had fired the employee, brushed the disaster under the carpet and moved on with their path to coffee-dominance.

Instead, the company leaders took the decision to close 8,000 stores, sacrificing  several million dollars in the process, to enroll their employees in an afternoon of Unconscious Bias Training.

The Starbucks bosses looked at the situation, acknowledged that the company (and the United States at large, though that’s a much wider issue) have a problem with racism, and attempted to make a genuine step towards tackling the issue.

There’s debate over whether or not the training will actually work in the long run. Regardless, the brand took an honest approach to acknowledging the problem and made their next steps transparent to the public.

The sheer volume of column inches dedicated to this process are evidence of the PR risk involved in an open and transparent strategy. In this instance, Starbucks left themselves open to criticism, but stood by their proposed solution in the name of working for the public good.

 

4. KFC

It’s no closely guarded secret that KFC have experienced some branding hardships in recent weeks and months, following the forced closure of 900 shops due to supply shortages.

The marketing team were backed into a corner on this occasion, they couldn’t deny anything had gone wrong; thousands of hungry consumers had been denied their fried-chicken fix. They had to be honest and apologise, but no one expected them to be so explicitly honest.

KFC_ApologyAd18

Their ‘FCK’ advert was lauded as a huge success, turning the whole debacle from a PR nightmare to somewhat of a dream; scarcity builds demand after all, as sales rocketed in the weeks immediately following the reconnection of their supply chain.

 

Conclusion

It’s hard to think of a single brand that fully embraces an honest approach to business. The steps taken by these brands, each one a move towards more honest practices, can only be considered a step in the right direction for wider consumer understanding of what goes on behind closed doors.

In a competitive environment where brand secrets are guarded closely, an honest approach to marketing, branding or crisis resolution can land considerable favour with the public.

Honesty is a virtue worth aiming for, and while it might not be an achievable goal for brands, we applaud these companies for taking the first step in the right direction.

To hear what consumers say about your brand behind your back, get in touch with us today.

For more on the factors that contribute to a brand being deemed as trustworthy or untrustworthy, read our recent report on brand trust.

Related posts



The New CMOs Guide to Rethinking Brand Strategy at Struggling Companies

The reasons behind the failure of a company are numerous. Perhaps their pricing plan was too ambitious; maybe they failed to innovate to stay ahead of nippier competitors; or perhaps they didn’t migrate successfully online.

Posted by Hannah Kate Kelly on September 18, 2018


Questions You Need To Be Asking This Week

Consumer sentiment changes every hour of every day. Knowing what customers are thinking is the key to making good decisions for your brand. Here are the top stories affecting consumers this week. Keeping your finger on the pulse, made easy. 

 

How can you transform your in-store experience?

Hardly a week goes by without the plight of high street retailers hitting the newspapers. It’s clear that brands need to fight harder for our footfall, and make more of an effort to impress us once we’ve passed the threshold of their shop door. One set of businesses defying the online trend, are French grands magasins. Last year, these department stores’ profits grew by 4.1%, outperforming the wider clothes market by 3.7%. Paolo de Cesare—head of Le Printemps, one of the grands magasins—thinks it’s because of their attitude to in-store experience. “There is a French way,” which offers shoppers “uniqueness, differentiation and experiences.” Currently, Le Bon Marché has a bright pink skate ramp suspended from the ceiling of its Paris store. While, in LA, they’ve gone, well, LA; pop-up food stalls, an in-store yoga studio, and a tattoo artist. With creative stunts and added extras drawing in consumers, it might be time to think about redefining what your in-store experience looks like to give it that certain je ne sais quoi.

Posted by Hannah Kate Kelly on September 17, 2018


Why Consumer Insight Should Be Owned by the CMO

Chief Marketing Officers sit right at the top of the Marketing tree. While being up high is useful when it comes to seeing the bigger, strategic picture, it does also mean they can be several strata away from front-line marketing, and direct consumer interactions. 

Posted by Hannah Kate Kelly on August 24, 2018


How Dynamic Media Planning Can Skyrocket Your Ad Effectiveness

Introduction

Everybody knows that adverts—both good and bad—can make you want to talk about them. The John Lewis Christmas ad never fails to elicit a Twitter storm of festive love. The Trivago woman drove Londoners collectively up the wall. Ofcom are regularly inundated with complaints about ads being misleading, offensive, or harmful. 

Posted by Hannah Kate Kelly on August 21, 2018