Who really cares if brands are ethical?

September 01, 2016 - 5 minute read

I can't remember the last time I bought a product that wasn’t simultaneously Fairtrade, organic, sustainable and full of integrity. These are the buzzwords we use to justify our spending habits.

But what if consumers don’t actually care about ethical practices? What if, in fact, an expensive marketing campaign is all that’s needed to convince a customer that brands have ethical commitments?

We asked respondents across the UK:

Screen Shot 2017-06-23 at 14.29.44.png

Is Kingsmill notorious for its ethical practices? Not really. As it happens, all four brands have nearly identical ethical practices. Hardly surprising, given that they’re all owned by the same parent company, Allied Bakeries.

Allied Bakeries has a fairly standard industry approach to ethical commitments, neither a villain nor a hero. They sign up to safe working conditions, pay living wages and claim to operate sustainable agricultural practices. All good things.

At the same time, Oxfam’s Behind the Brands campaign - which aims to provide people who buy food and drink products with the information they need to hold companies to account for what happens in their supply chains – has found areas in which Associated British Foods, Allied Bakeries’ parent company, falls short. It scores a measly 3/10 in measuring its impact on small-scale farmers and fares equally badly in its commitment to supporting women.

Oxfam also notes that Associated British Foods struggles with transparency. It provides some information about where it sources its raw materials, but is not forthcoming on its suppliers and auditing. Yet 50.2% of our respondents presume that Kingsmill is a responsible business with ethical trading.

Big means blameless

Burgen, Allinson and Sunblest appear to have injected so little into marketing over the last few years that their campaigns barely register on the internet. But Kingsmill tells a different story, channeling £30m into campaigns since 2007.

A £14m TV advertising campaign in 2007 saw Kingsmill celebrate “real life and real families”, marking the start of a commitment to forging an emotional relationship with its consumers. In 2009, they built on this, spending £11m on three tongue-in-cheek TV adverts showing the modern family. This was topped off with a £6.3m logo redesign in 2015 to leave Kingsmill feeling “warmer and more accessible”, largely achieved by putting sunshine on its packaging.

In effect, what we’re seeing is that out of the four brands of bread, Kingsmill has become the most visible. And for consumers, visibility implies reliability. The bigger the brand, the more easily consumers presume – rather than verify – its codes of conduct.

Surviving scandal

To be fair to Kingsmill, while it enjoys an ethical appearance somewhat off of the back of its marketing campaigns, it does also operate generally acceptable ethical practices. But what about companies who have nurtured an ethical image despite their unethical practices? What happens when these malpractices are publicly exposed? As it turns out, very little. Consumer commitment does not appear to waiver.

In June 2016, we asked respondents across the UK:

Screen Shot 2017-06-23 at 14.30.19.pngIt’s not surprising that Volkswagen comes out top, having been plagued by revelations about their car emissions tests since 2015. But as an automaker, these disclosures didn’t shatter an ethical brand image that had been painstakingly nurtured: no one really expected a car manufacturer to be committed to sustainable practices.

The fact that just 12.4% of respondents associated Marks & Spencer with a corporate scandal is more interesting. Particularly since just ten days before this survey, Marks & Spencer made front-page news when their Chief Executive, Steve Rowe, forecast pay cuts for staff.

Within three days a petition to prevent these cuts had garnered 20,000 signatures online, the issue was subsequently raised in Parliament and cross-party MPs turned out to support a protest outside its flagship store in Marble Arch.

Yet our respondents didn’t register this. Could it have something to do with the fact that since 2010 Marks & Spencer has more than doubled its digital marketing budget, and formed an ever-closer relationship with consumers? Digital marketing now accounts for more than 25% of its total marketing budget.

This is not just a marketing campaign, this is an M&S marketing campaign. And it allows the company to shed negative publicity surrounding their ethical practices in a way that other companies can't.

All publicity is good publicity

So, the good news is that for companies who have invested in crafting an ethical brand image, revelations of exploitation won’t alienate their customer base.

We asked respondents across the UK:

Have you ever boycotted a company following a corporate scandal?

Screen Shot 2017-06-23 at 14.31.02.png
Almost 70% said No.

Sustainable practices are expensive. And what this data tells brands is that the expense may not be worth it.

With this kind of data, delivered quickly and anonymously, brands can better understand how customers actually operate, instead of how they tell you they operate. In this case, the findings offer a message that we at Attest are reluctant to convey: brands don’t need to be ethical.

But why stop here? New insights can be gained all the time. Get started.

Related posts

5 Perspectives on The Brands to Watch in 2018

Who's going to stand out this year? Will brands that took a battering in 2017 make a statement in 2018? Will it be the year of challenger brands or incumbents?

To bring you answers to these questions (and more), we reached out to 5 experts with very different backgrounds across startups, content, social media, experiential marketing and audio to share their unique perspectives on who are the brands to watch in 2018.

Alison Battisby, Founder, Avocado Social

Monzo: The digital mobile-only challenger bank saw nearly half a million new users sign up for its services and claim their bright orange bank cards last year. Monzo is a fantastic way to manage your budget thanks to their instant updates in the app showing you how much you've just spent, and provide added value when used abroad thanks to their free withdrawls up to £200. 

Having just received their full UK banking license from the FCA and PRA in 2017, Monzo is rolling out "the best current account in the world". With their slick app and excellent communication, they are playing to millennials by offering a unique customer experience and we're set to see even more new banking features in 2018. 
Sanctus:  The mental health startup based in London has the vision to create the world's first mental health gym, where people can go and work out their mental health fitness as they would their physical fitness. Right now, the company is working with businesses to create space within a company for people to take time off and talk to a Sanctus coach. In 2018, the company aims to work with 50 business partners and continue to spread awareness of mental health. Founder   James Routledge   writes an excellent weekly newsletter on mental health and growing the startup, which is honestly written and is well worth a read .
Neom Organics:  Hot off the heels of significant new investment, this Harrogate-based beauty and wellbeing brand is set to launch a new range of products in 2018, as well as new retail stores both in the UK and abroad. Neom was found by two friends, one of which was an ex Glamour magazine editor who realised her own wellbeing, and that of her close friends, was affected by the stress and demands of modern life. She quit journalism to train as an aromatherapist and nutritionist before founding Neom. The brand's products focus on improving people’s wellbeing through home fragrances and skincare. 
Adam Azor, Managing Director, Curb
My first pick is Pepsi. Lets be honest, Pepsi had an awful 2017 from a brand perspective, they created what they thought was going to be a work of advertising art, an ad that would change the world, but instead it turned them into a global laughing stock.
This is also on a backdrop of huge backlash and increased legislation against sugary drinks. The days when all they had to worry about was competing against Coca-Cola are probably looked on with nostalgia by the marketing team. However Pepsi are a brand with true marketing pedigree, iconic campaigns, partnerships and experiences.
I’m really interested to see how they come back. The test of a great brand is how they react when they are at their lowest. I will be watching Pepsi closely in 2018 to see what they have planned.

My second one to watch for 2018, is the darling of the Aim, BooHoo. The online based fashion retailer has gone through exceptional growth over the last few years, along with some very smart acquisitions.

However they are now at the point where brand building is becoming as important as performance marketing. I expect an innovative business such as BooHoo to evolve its marketing activity to ensure it not only continues its business growth but becomes a brand leader in its own right.

This will be a year to watch brands take the design aspect of their branding in new and exciting directions.

Posted by Mark Walker on January 16, 2018

10 Ways To Understand and Shift Your Brand Perception in 2018

Think you know what your brand represents? I’ll let you in on a little secret; it’s not what you say in your slogan, brand values or advertisements. It’s whatever consumers say you are.

Posted by Bel Booker on January 09, 2018

5 Things That the Strongest Brands Focus on

Nothing lasts forever.

Posted by Mark Walker on January 08, 2018

5 New Year Resolutions to Help Your Brand in 2018

New Year resolutions don't just have to be for individuals. The idea of improving, quitting bad habits and enjoying a more productive, successful year can be just as valid for business and teams. 

Here are some resolutions you may want to consider for your brand to avoid the pitfalls others experienced in 2017.

Posted by Alex Rees on January 05, 2018